Old School RuneScape (OSRS) is home to a massive inventory of around 13,000 items, each with its own unique purpose, rarity, and value. Some of these items are extremely rare and coveted by players, whether because of their limited availability, their limited-time nature, or the fact that they’re simply no longer obtainable. In this article, we’ll take a deep dive into the rarest OSRS items, starting with discontinued items, and we’ll even throw in a bonus section on the rarest items you can wear, for that ultimate flex.

Discontinued Items: A Blast from the Past

Let’s start with a category of items that are no longer available in the game: discontinued items. These items were once available during events or updates, but due to their limited nature, they are now some of the rarest collectibles in OSRS.

Rancid Turkey (2013 Thanksgiving Event)

Released during the 2013 Thanksgiving event, the Rancid Turkey was initially called Cooked Turkey. It couldn’t be banked, which meant that it became a rare commodity once the event ended. While it’s not likely that many Rancid Turkeys remain in the game, those that do are likely held by accounts that have not logged in for years. Imagine an account with a full inventory of Rancid Turkeys trying to complete the Fight Caves. If someone manages that, it would be a sight to behold!

Pumpkin Pie (2021 Halloween Event)

In 2021, OSRS introduced the Pumpkin Pie, but there was controversy surrounding its release. The item could be smuggled out of a cutscene and traded on the Grand Exchange (GE) due to a bug, which led to players spending millions of OSRS gold to acquire it. Jagex, however, deleted these items from inventories and banks, which caused outrage. The only remaining Pumpkin Pies are those still sitting on the Grand Exchange, making them some of the rarest items in the game.

Not Meat (2024 Event)

In 2024, a bizarre item called Not Meat was introduced. This item, dropped by Kbits on the Baramore island, was traded for only an hour before it was deleted. It looked like meat and had a strange name, leading to confusion and intrigue. While most of these have likely been removed, some may still exist in private storage units or on the Grand Exchange.

Old Agility Arena Tickets (2024 Update)

In 2024, the Brimhaven Agility Arena underwent a revamp, which included the introduction of new agility tickets. The old tickets were rendered obsolete, making them a rare collectible. If you still have some in your bank, you possess a piece of OSRS history.

Pieces of Eight (Trouble Brewing)

The Pieces of Eight were rewards from the Trouble Brewing minigame, which could be traded for currency or used to purchase rewards. With the update in 2024 that introduced a new reward system, these items were discontinued. If you happen to have a few lying around, they are now among the rarest items in the game.

2024: A Year of Discontinued Items

It seems like 2024 was a year of significant updates that resulted in several discontinued items. Alongside the Agility Arena changes, the Forestry Event brought about the removal of items like Powdered Pollen, Clover Insignia, Leprechaun Charm, and others. These items were initially used to trigger Forestry events but were ultimately disliked by players, leading to their removal. As with other discontinued items, any that remain are a rare sight.

Old Clue Caskets (2016 Update)

In 2016, Jagex introduced an update to clue scrolls that removed the old clue reward caskets from the game. These caskets were previously obtainable through x-mark-the-spot locations and could contain another clue when opened. Once the update hit, these caskets were replaced with new versions, making the old ones increasingly rare. If you still have one of these caskets, it’s one of the most unique and rare items in OSRS.

Bird Nests and Nest Boxes (2016 and 2019 Updates)

Bird Nests and Nest Boxes were updated multiple times over the years. The changes to these items resulted in several versions existing in the game, some of which have been lost over time due to their opening. While some old versions may still exist, every time they’re opened, they are replaced with the new versions, making the older ones even more rare.

Rare Quest Items and One-Timers

Some of the rarest items in OSRS aren’t discontinued, but they are rare due to their limited usage or the fact that they are only used in a single quest or event. These “one-timer” items are considered incredibly rare because they are consumed or rendered useless once the associated quest is completed.

Ferro Scepter (2022 Update)

In April 2022, the Ferro Scepter was given an upgrade to the number of charges it holds. However, players who had the old version of the item before the update found that it was no longer usable. While these scepters are now extremely rare, especially if they are not converted to the new version, they are virtually useless in terms of gameplay.

Fake Dragon Hosta KP (2019 Glitch)

The Dragon Hosta KP was introduced in 2019 and accidentally made tradable. Due to this glitch, some of these items became known as the Fake Dragon Hosta KP. They can’t be used or traded anymore, but they remain as an interesting artifact of the game’s history. If you own one of these, you have a unique piece of OSRS’s bug-ridden past.

Makeover Vouchers (2022)

The Makeover Voucher was originally a reward for male players completing the Recruitment Drive quest, allowing them to change their character’s gender. However, this item was removed from the game in 2022, and its ability to be claimed was abolished as part of a diversity and inclusion update. While the vouchers are no longer obtainable, those who kept them as placeholders in their bank can still see the item.

The Rarest Wearable Items: For That Flex

While some rare items are primarily for collectors, others have real in-game value or can be worn for the ultimate flex. Here are a few of the rarest wearable items in OSRS that you can proudly flaunt.

Free-to-Play Starter Pack (2015)

Released in 2015, the Free-to-Play Starter Pack was a special item for OSRS players during its early years. This pack contained 18 items, including a Blue Wizard Hat (one of the most valuable items in the pack). These packs were only available during a limited-time event and were distributed to moderators and famous community members. If you have one of these packs, you’re among the rare few who can wear a piece of OSRS history.

The Useless Key

The Useless Key is a strange item introduced as part of the Taste of Hope quest. It was never intended to be seen by players and was only introduced as a placeholder for the Shortcut Key. Because it serves no purpose and is so rare, it has become an incredibly interesting piece of OSRS lore.

Shortcut Key Placeholder

While not an item you can wear, the Shortcut Key is an item obtained through the Darkness of Hollow Veil quest. The placeholder for this key, due to its obscure nature, is an extremely rare item, making it a must-have for collectors.

Conclusion

Old School RuneScape has no shortage of rare items, whether they are discontinued due to glitches or simply because of the limited time they were available. These rare items hold significant value, both for collectors and for those looking to flex their in-game achievements. From the quirky Rancid Turkey to the iconic Fake Dragon Hosta KP, each item tells a story of OSRS’s rich history and unique events.

If you happen to be lucky enough to own one of these rare items, consider yourself part of an exclusive group. Whether you’re using them to show off or simply holding onto them as a piece of OSRS history, these items are more than just collectibles—they’re testaments to the game’s evolving journey. Keep an eye on future updates, as OSRS always has the potential for new rare items to join the ranks of the most coveted treasures in the game.